1810 – Abram Brown, Founder

1st– Elder William Clopton 
2nd– Elder James Clopton
 3rd– Elder James H. Christian

Samuel Brown (First Colored Pastor) 1865 – 1881
Thomas H. Jonson 1882 – 1905
Lewis H. Dickenson 1906 – 1909
Wesley P. Curl 1908 – 1913
John W. Kemp 1914 – 1923
Miles M. Fisher 1926 – 1928
Gordon B. Hancock 1923 – 1925
George W. Watkins 1928 – 1969
James W. Mills 1969 – 1972
James W. Hayes 1972 – 2011
Edgar Street 2012 – 2014

Rev. Dr. Horace B. Parham, Jr. 2006 – 2017
Rev. Dr. Helen Washington-Randall 2018 – present